Jail Analysis

What I found
Four counties in four states were planning bigger jails. In each, I looked instead at what the plans had left out.

Over the years, I’ve been asked to help counties plan new jails, and I’ve always responded by offering something else: a study of how they’re using the jails they have.

In four counties — Contra Costa, CA; Jackson, MO; Franklin, OH; and Fulton, GA — county leaders had hired architects, construction firms, and analysts to answer one question: how many jail beds to build, based on assumptions about how many people they would incarcerate.

But a jail is a place: a building, its staff, its operations. Who fills that building, on the other hand, is the downstream consequence of upstream policy decisions: the ones police, prosecutors, courts, and probation make about who gets locked up, and why. A bigger building doesn’t change those decisions; it only makes room for more of their consequences.

So before anything gets built, I insist on looking at the whole system: who is being brought into the jail, for how long, and what happens to them while they’re inside.

In Contra Costa County in 2015, where I wrote the program design for the County’s jail needs assessment, the architectural plan had accounted for where people would be held, but not for how they would stay connected with loved ones while inside or be prepared to succeed on the outside.

In Jackson County in 2018, my partners and I found that 83 percent of the people in the main jail were awaiting trial, against two-thirds nationally, in a system whose agencies rarely worked together. The real question wasn’t how many cells to add — it was why this siloed system was driving so many people into custody in the first place.

When a new jail was already being built in Franklin County in 2018, I offered the County a new design for rehabilitative programming — one that starts at intake. Until then, intake had focused on operational concerns; my approach began with identifying and responding to what each person needed so they could leave better off.

In Fulton County in 2022, my partners and I co-authored a jail population review for the Atlanta City Council. In the 250 cases we examined, 68 percent were held up by procedural delays. What kept people in jail was the process: felonies waiting for indictment, competency hearings reset again and again, and a release rule requiring a street address that people without homes couldn’t give.

In all four counties, the plans accounted for the beds. I asked them, instead, to focus on the people who would fill them.

This is what I call an “orphan opportunity”: a moment of potential for great change, if only somebody would look.